Medical Information Distribution Service: Minds defines a clinical guideline as “a document that evaluates the total body of evidence through a systematic review and presents recommendations that are considered optimal, taking into account the balance of benefits and harms, in order to support decision making by healthcare users and providers on important health issues.” Minds also presents a series of guideline development methods, from the formulation of the clinical question, systematic review, synthesis and evaluation of evidence, and development of the recommendation statement. While this method is extremely useful for clinical questions for which high quality evidence can be obtained through systematic review, it is difficult to apply to clinical questions for which high quality evidence is difficult to obtain. Alternative methods include summarizing expert consensus or consensus statements, or describing narrative reviews. Regardless of the method used, the guideline development process should specify the purpose of the guideline development, the members who will develop it, how it will be developed, and how it will be published.
View full abstract